Watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. Nov 12, 2015 harry potter and the sorcerers stone, the first book and movie, is set in 1991, with each following release taking place in each subsequent year, ending in 1997 the novels were completed in 2007, and the films in 2011, just for comparisons sake. What are the major differences between the harry potter novels and. Did the setting in the movie look like you had imagined it. Rowling brought us the world of harry potter and endowed it with an impressive number of. Did harry potter really steal all these story ideas. In the book, harrys banned from playing after the first game, in which malfoys taunting gets to him and the weasley twins, provoking a fight. Published in 2007, it follows harry, ron and hermiones quest to find the four remaining horcruxes, which are magical artifacts which hold pieces of voldemorts soul. Harry potter and the goblet of firebookmovie comparison. Thats when he realizes he doesnt know much about the wizarding world i. Its been 11 years since the last book was released, seven years since the last movie hit theaters, and yet the ip is as strong. What were the challenges to get to the sorcerers stone. I defended this as educational, claiming that we were going to compare and contrast the book and movie.
How would you rank the harry potter books and movies. Probably the largest single overt omission from the entire movie series was the. Personally i would have thought it better if harry potter was on the front and the dragon on the back, as when the box is on a bookcaseshelf and closed you can only see the dragon. Hermiones hair is frizzy, like its supposed to be, ron looks like i imagined him, but j. Jun 07, 2016 comparisons of the timeturner scenes in harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban. Almost no book to movie transition is, but i wont deny the beauty of the films. Fluffy, devils snare, keys, chess, mirror of erised. What if the characters of harry potter looked like they did in the books. And in harry potter and the halfblood prince, at first glance, youll find its rather similar in both the book and the film. I have only seen the first harry potter movie, though ive read all the books, so i can only offer an opinion on that one. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets compare and.
Most of these differences include characters and scenes. What plot points are missing in the harry potter movies that. What are the differences and similarities between the. List of differences between the harry potter books and films. It is about the adventure of an elevenyearold boy who grew up with his aunt and uncle and later discovers that he comes from a family of witches and wizards. Naruto uzumaki is a predestined hero to save his world like harry.
Get an answer for comparison between the movie and the book harry potter and the sorcerers stone i have been asked to write an essay about the differences in the book and the movie version of. However, stretching a 54page book into three fulllength films could be a tough task, and the films could suffer from unfavorable comparisons to the original harry potter films. Whats the difference between harry potter and the philosophers stone the book and harry potter and the philosophers stone the movie. I am an avid harry potter fan, and i obviously love the movies too. A movie that came out in 2002 was harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Rowling, called harry potter and the sorcerers stone. The harry potter books and movies have always walked together handinhand. Harry potter was still the first movie of its kind, featuring an entire wizarding world and school whereas several avengers heroes had. In 20, 78 books were turned into the movies, based on the website popsugar. Peeves was prevalent in every book, and the troublemaker never made it easy for students, teachers and especially the. How different are the harry potter movies from the books.
Like thousands of readers, i have read the book and then watched the movie of harry potter. The book harry potter and the sorcerers stone differs from the movie harry potter and the sorcerers stone in many ways. Charlie and the chocolate factory 1964 is a childrens book by welsh author roald dahl. It also chronicles the final battle between voldemort and harry. Releasing the films based on the written books like what happened to harry potter is the best experience a reader expects. Why take the risk by returning the wand to dumbledores grave when you can destroy the wand once and for all. Jk rowling created an empire when she began writing her wizarding world of harry potter book. I always thought the harry potter wizardry world was perfect to create a video game, i think most of us can agree with this. Also, they totally left out harry s dream, the one with quirrells turban. Because of the directors slavish devotion to include every little incident from the novel, the. I know what youre thinking harry potter and the sorcerers stone is the closest book tofilm translation youve ever seen. Dec 14, 2017 what if the characters of harry potter looked like they did in the books.
One of the biggest differences between the harry potter books and movies is that the books have way, way more information. Imagine a video game with an open world, where you can choose your blood status, wand, magic school, job, etc. Movie october 16, 20 february 21, 2014 even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. Goblet of fire opened better than any harry potter movie to date, so its likely that the dvd wont be on store shelves until march at the earliest. From harry s famous green eyes being changed to blue to narcissa malfoys unique twotone do, heres how the harry potter characters transformed from page to screen, and why they were reimagined for the films. The harry potter franchise is a global phenomenon like few others. Harry potter book character descriptions versus how they. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter. I must say, harry potter and the chamber of secrets was probably my least favorite movie of them all.
Harry s plan in the book could go wrong in numerous ways. I know it says bookish item, and then i put movies in the title but hear me out haha. I dont know if the elder wand was indeed breakable like what is shown in the movie. I feel that the harry potter film series slightly messed up the final battle. I still love them more than most other movies, and harry potter is a story ill bring with me wherever i go. Naruto creator addresses harry potter comparisons anime. Books harry had always been skinny and small for his age. Differences between harry potter and the deathly hallows. Harry, ron and hermione, the main trio, go to hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry for their sixth year. In harry potter and the sorcerers stone, harry, an orphan, lives with the dursleys, his horrible aunt and. At any rate, i thought the first film was dreadful. It is not because the book was bad, if anything it was because the book was good. When comparing a book and a film, or something similar, the first thing one thinks about is obviously the plot.
Harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off. In the book harry first hears about quidditch from draco malfoy while in diagon alley before hagrid explains what it is after harry met up with him. Movie with all the new movies based on books or comics that are out, people wonder why hollywood keeps doing it. Another significant difference between the first book and movie is how harry potter meets and interacts with draco malfoy for the first time. Below are a list of changes made to the stories of the harry potter books when they were adapted into feature films. What are the differences and similarities between the harry.
Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter movies and. It is the first novel in the harry potter series and rowlings debut novel, first published in 1997 by bloomsbury. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban 2004 scene comparisons. Rowling harry potter and the philosophers stone is a fantasy novel written by british author j. Harry potter and the deathly hallows is the seventh and last book in the harry potter series. Differences or badly implemented scenes harry gets his broomstick and has an epic pursuit with the dragon task 3 harry gets his broomstick and easily steals the egg theme is obviously very well composed and everybody associates it with harry potter. Later on, he is free to roam diagon alley to get other books etc. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone was the first of seven book series by j.
The movies actually start out following the books pretty well. What plot points are missing in the harry potter movies. Oct 05, 20 if youve only seen the harry potter movies and havent read the books, than there a few things that you might not know. If youve only seen the harry potter movies and havent read the books, than there a few things that you might not know these differences are more pronounced as the books grow larger and the story more complex, but lets start with the first one. Ron claims that harry potter speakes parseltongue in his sleep, and he remembered that to open the door. So, when the prisoner of azkaban movie was released 10 years ago on june 4. The movie starts out with dumbledore on the dursleys. Nevertheless, both the movie and the book prove to be equally entertaining despite their differences. Dec 28, 2007 harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban book and movie differences were adding in differences as we find them, but if you notice that weve left something out, please email us at corrections. Meaning that unless you already knew, you probably wouldnt realise it was a harry potter book set. Differences between harry potter and the philosophers. Comparative analysis harry potter books vs movies yuri. Fans of the book series were left confused when the usually faithful movies failed to provide a satisfactory story about the marauders and their.
One example of a childrens book that portrays this image and has been popular all over the world is harry potter and the sorcerers stone by j. Harry potter and the goblet of fire study guides and book. Alas, when the potter movies got the movie treatment, adhering to the novels 100% would have been impossible so, some minor or, in some cases, major changes were made. While i didnt expect to be first in line for the final harry potter movie, at 11 p. During goblet of fire, both book and movie, peter pettigrew. The first part of the book is little more than an account of everyday life in a magical landscape. This movie was based off the bestselling novel, which was written in 1997 by j. Also in harry potter 6 in the book they have a meeting on the train with professor slughorn and the rest of the slug club. Ive read the books countless times mostly because i was to embarrassed to keep count over 30, and one of the most serious forms of punishment i received when i was a kid was when my mom threatened to take away my harry potter books.
Harry potter how hes described in the books harry had a thin face, knobbly knees, black hair and brightgreen eyes. What are differences between harry potter books and movies. These differences are more pronounced as the books grow larger and the story more complex, but lets start with the first one. Harry and ginnys first kiss is my favorite part in the whole series, and i was so disappointed that they changed it in the movies.
The book describes an elaborate conversational battle between harry and voldemort, where harry reveals secrets and insights to voldemort and everyone like snape s true allegiance, elder wand s real. Fantastic beasts and where to find them jumps back in time 65 years, to 1926. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone movie was very accurate to the book, but just didnt have important details like how harry potter s eyes are green, the sorting hat didnt sort right and sing a song, and how at the end of the book, there was no potions task in general. In the book, harry gets his copy of the monster book of monsters by owl post from hagrid, along with the newspaper clipping of the weasleys holidaying in egypt which shows scabbers, birthday cards and the sneakoscope. Harry potter and the order of the phoenix ive read the book, ive seen the movie, now heres the differences obviously, this is one big spoiler fest, so youre been warned. For fans, the comparisons of naruto and harry potter are often straightforward ones.
Americas characters compare to their reallife counterparts the series about the 1970s era ratification effort doesnt need to digress from history for the sake of a good story. The novel harry potter and the goblet of fire is story full of adventure, action, and suspense, but only after the first 400 pages. But with harry potter about to rule our worlds yet again thanks to the new movie, its a safe bet that the cries of unoriginal will start up yet again so its worth examining them ahead of. The bluray edition of philosophers stone includes commentary from director chris columbus that reveals that the final scene of the film where harry, hermione and ron depart. Why was the ending of the book different from the ending of the movie in regards to the elder wand. Apr 08, 2011 harry potter and the deathly hallows is the seventh and last book in the harry potter series. Books, movies, games, and now it has even dominated the liveplaytheatre division too. The movie had a lot of gaps, parts where what happened in the book did not ever even come up in the movie. Goblet of fire opened better than any harry potter movie to date, so it. Compare contrast harry potter movie and book free essays. A comparison of the plots and characters in charlie and the chocolate factory as they appear in the original book by roald dahl and in the movie adaptation.
When it comes to harry, i love them both but there are a lot of details left out if you only see the movie. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone book vs movie essay. The story is about an ordinary boy, harry potter, who is whisked away to a fanciful world of witchcraft and wizardry. List of differences between the harry potter books and films harry. Browse other questions tagged harry potter adaptation comparison deathlyhallows or ask your own question. Its 2018over 10 years since the book release of harry potter and. The third movie and subsequent ones left out a ton of the books, but have become better movies. Jul 30, 2019 the harry potter franchise is a global phenomenon like few others.
Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban 2004 scene. Part ii 2011, harry potter and the sorcerers stone 2001, finding dory 2016, harry potter and the goblet of fire 2005, harry potter and the order of the phoenix 2007 having trouble thinking of good comparisons. November marks the release of several movies based on young adult novels, which makes it the perfect time for this kind of study. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter movies and books. But everyone now knows that the elder wand belonged to dumbledore.
Bookish item ranking the harry potter movies the book. Let me preface this by saying that harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban is my favorite book of the entire series. Whats the difference between harry potter and the deathly hallows the book and harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 the movie. Dec 02, 2016 wow harry potter truly dominates every form of media nowadays. What are the differences and similarities between the harry potter and the philosophers stone book and movie.
In the first movie, the sorcerers stone, nearly everything is just like its book counterpart. Oct 16, 20 harry potter and the chamber of secrets. Harry potter and the order of the phoenix ive read the book, ive seen the movie, now here. A harry potter fan might fret that no one explains where the maurading map came from, or how cool dumbledores funeral would have been to see, or where peeves disappeared to, but they dont really matter in a movie sense. Rowling brought us the world of harry potter and endowed it with an impressive number of secrets. First of all, books harry potter characters appearances are somehow more humorous than they are in the movies. Considering this thesis came out to 17 singlespaced pages in word, ill make this intro here brief. Harry potter moviebook comparison sorcerers stone quiz. Some say theyre greedy people, just doing it for the money, and others say that it helps bring the book to life. After doing the harry potter books ranking, i also wanted to do a movie ranking. From my comparison of the book harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban and its movie adaptation, it is clear that there are a lot of similarities and differences between the two. The two ways to discover this harry potter adventure are to either read the book or watch the movie.
Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of narnia series, and where. The film series, by the nature of film and the necessities of making movies that could equally. Harry potter movies ranked from worst to best collider. Mar 28, 2014 ive never met a movie i like more than the book. Jul 12, 2014 let me preface this by saying that harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban is my favorite book of the entire series. List of differences between the harry potter books and. Which centaurs does harry meet in the forbidden forest. Also, in the film, harry met draco on the train when in the book, he met him while trying on robes. Differences between harry potter and the philosophers stone.
Here are some, from harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Plus slughorn keeps inviting harry and hermione to more slug club meetings harry is always busy and ron gets really angry at them because he is being excluded. Harry doesnt want to use the elder wand or let it fall into the wrong hands. Harry also has very messy hair rather than straight which the description gives audience an impression that main character harry potter is a boy who shares. Compare and contrast a book and movie activities my first year teaching when i was constantly running on empty i slipped several movie watching afternoons into my lesson plans. Ron first gets the keeper job in book 5 instead of movie 6, but isnt very good at it prompting a slytherin song.
667 791 125 1259 1494 961 901 73 1050 749 64 401 1145 796 512 203 92 460 90 1090 564 1368 1447 1036 480 327 1298 716 1074 784 921 202 388 365 1187 71 1000 486 155 375 283 1212 62 542